• Join
  • Login
  • GTO Twitter
  • GTO Facebook
  • 00:51:23 AEST
  • Friday, 19 October 2018
Horses default

Is Winx better than Black Caviar?


After winning the George Rider by seven lengths on a heavy 10 at Rosehill last Saturday, punters all over Australia's have risen to a new level of admiration for the great mare Winx. Twelve months ago Australian racing commentators were whispering the idea that the star mare may be better than Australia's undefeated champion Black Caviar. With Winx having now notched-up sixteen consecutive wins, with each one seemingly coming easier for her, that whisper is becoming louder. Racing commentators are now going on record to declare that Winx is better than Black Caviar.

Versatility

Comparing race horses isn't an easy business, especially when you consider that Black Caviar was a specialist sprinter, racing between 1000m to 1400m. But here lies a key point for those making the claim. Winx's versatility is one of the key things capturing the hearts of Australian punters having now won stakes races at 1200m, 2200m and distances in between.

Twenty-four of her twenty-six starts have been at stakes level, including both weight-for-age and handicap races.

While she probably hasn't met the best sprinters in Australia at the shorter distances, there's not doubting the quality of her opposition from middle distances and upwards. The George Ryder place getters included Group 1 winner and recognised mud-lark Le Romain and star galloper Chautauqua. Other beaten rivals include Black Heart Bart, Hauraki, Hartnell, Criterion and Happy Clapper, to name a few.

 

Getting Better

Chris Waller stated that he was surprised how easily Winx won on Saturday considering the conditions. Who's to know how far she would have won by had she gone into fourth or even fifth gear.

Waller is not known for talking-up his runners. He's gone on record to say that he didn't understand the notion of a horse coming back from a spell bigger and better than ever. That is until he trained Winx and witnessed her run in the George Ryder on Saturday - admitting this week that "...she's come back bigger and stronger". In support of Waller's claim, anyone suggesting that she could improve after last year's back-to-back Cox Plate effort would have been laughed at by even the most optimistic trainer. After Saturday's effort however, you would struggle to find anyone who disagrees that she is actually better.

lads

Consistency

There's no doubt that Black Caviar's unbeaten record over 25 career starts is a milestone that won't be surpassed in our life time. The last time that Winx saw the back of a rival as she passed the winning post was back when she was a three-year-old filly, since then she has been undefeated. At the earliest, punters will have to wait until this time next year to see if she can match Black Caviar's 25 in-a-row record, but going on recent form, it's hard to see how she won't.

Prize Money

Career earnings for Winx have now passed $10 million. If she wins her next start, she will pass Sunline's career prize money with only triple Melbourne Cup winner Makybe Diva left to pass.

Winx's next test comes in the Queen Elizabeth Stakes at Randwick on April 1, when she attempts to get her first victory over 2200m. It's not a distance that is foreign to her though. She was runner-up in the Australian Oaks at Randwick as a three-year-old, and now that she's bigger and better than ever, she will be well and truly up to it.

Before you decide who is better, learn more about the career of Black Caviar at theGreatTipOff.com.

Mike Steward

Share On:

Top Stories

Caulfield Cup Trophy

Caulfiled Tips: Cup Preview 2018

Distance 2400m Grade Group 1 Track Rating Good 4 Prizemoney $5,000,000 .....

Oct 18, 2018 07:17PM
READ MORE right-arrow

Randwick racecourse overcast

20/10/18 Randwick Tips: best bets on key races

As the Everest dust settles from last week's flagship meeting at Randwick, we are still left with the likelihoo.....

Oct 18, 2018 07:08PM
READ MORE right-arrow

Test The World

Randwick Tips: The Nivision Preview 2018

Distance 1200m Grade Group 3 Track Rating Heavy 8 Prizemoney $160,000 .....

Oct 18, 2018 04:20PM
READ MORE right-arrow

Form Guide Lay

Saturday racing Lays of the Day 20 October 2018

With wet conditions and a severely rain affected racing surface again likely at Randwick this week, expect there to be p.....

Oct 18, 2018 03:50PM
READ MORE right-arrow

Betting Offers

click and get your bonus today!

* NEW ACC ONLY, EXC NSW, SA, WA & VIC. TURNOVER REQUIREMENTS & EXPIRY PERIOD APPLY. SEE T&CS ON WEBSITE. GAMBLE RESPONSIBLY.



Racing News Topics


Tweets by @theGreatTipOff


Yesterday's Racing Top 5

Mosse
Pro
370% POT
smokybay
Punter
317% POT
ozdaboy
Punter
237% POT
tridents
Punter
138% POT
Dragons26
Punter
114% POT
Full Leaderboard
Colin McNiff
78% POT
Ernie Mannin..
48% POT
Chris Scholt..
20% POT
Andrew Oldme..
16% POT
Simon Thomas
14% POT
 
Chris Scholt.. 20% POT
Andrew Oldme.. 16% POT
Simon Thomas 14% POT
Tony Brassel - 4% POT
Glenn McFarl.. - 5% POT
 

Next Race to Jump

More Racing news you might like

Form Guide Lay

Saturday racing Lays of the Day 20 October 2018

With wet conditions and a severely rain affected racing surface again likely at Randwick this week, expect there to be p.....

READ MORE right-arrow

Deane Lester Tipping Site

Lester followers profit from exclusive staking plan

Melbourne form analyst Deane Lester is one of the most respected names in racing. His comments and insights are becoming.....

READ MORE right-arrow

Horse racing game

16/10/18 Horse Racing Tipsters of the week

For racing fans, there is no better time of the year than right now. It's the time when the best horses come out to .....

READ MORE right-arrow

Bookie Ring 060218

17/10/18 Free Horse Racing Tips

Free racing tips from Ben Beare Randwick Kensington Race 1 Tip #5 Gumshoe $6.00 Trialled beautifully against Shelley B.....

READ MORE right-arrow

Land Of Plenty 200918

Caulfield Tips: Toorak Handicap Preview 2018

Distance 1600m Grade Group 1 Track Rating Good 4 Prizemoney $500,000 .....

READ MORE right-arrow

Caulfield finish

Caulfield Racing: Caulfield Stakes Preview 2018

Distance 2000m Grade Group 1 Track Rating Good 4 Prizemoney $1,000,000 .....

READ MORE right-arrow

Copyright  © 2018 S92 thegreattipoff.com | Stay in Control. Gamble responsibly.